Skip to content
Comparison

ChatGPT or Claude: which to choose — the ToTheMoon hosts' experience

OpenAI's ChatGPT and Anthropic's Claude are the two systems the ToTheMoon hosts consider the market leaders and compare most often. The podcast names no single winner: Alexander Volchek relies on ChatGPT in everyday life, while for development and automation he rates Anthropic's models higher. This page gathers where each system is stronger in the hosts' experience, what the limits and plans come down to, how the Dots assistant differs from Claude Duet, and how to tell whether one system is enough for you or you need both.

Updated November 16, 2026 · ToTheMoon editors · from the hosts' experience, no editorial ranking
Point by point

ChatGPT or Claude

What we compareChatGPTClaude
What the hosts use it forEveryday tasks, email and services: Alexander Volchek works in ChatGPT and Codex every day.Development, business processes and automation: for these, Alexander currently chooses Opus 5.5.
StrengthsIts own infrastructure: memory across thousands of chats, the Dots assistant, a Finance module linked to almost every US bank.Models for complex work: Fable sees a big task through, and Fable 5.2, Alexander says, is many times stronger at complex programming.
Limits and plansGood models long ran almost without limits, and the $500 Pro was unlimited even on Astra; now unlimited chat is going away.The limit runs in five-hour windows; on the $20 plan Fable is pointless; it burned through a $200 subscription in four to five hours.
Limit resets and accountsOpenAI hands out limit resets and officially allows multiple accounts.Anthropic can't afford resets; it doesn't allow multiple accounts and keeps up mass bans.
Assistant in one windowDots comes to you with suggestions on its own and, Alexander says, works independently of tokens.Claude Duet: Pro only, US only, via a waitlist; it can't see earlier Claude sessions and spends your tokens.
Memory and personalizationOver thousands of chats, the ChatGPT, Codex and Dots combination, Alexander says, has remembered where he lives and what he does.Anthropic has described memory that, while Claude sits idle, checks its notes against its work history and corrects mistakes.
Resumes and interviewsAccording to Anna Volchek, it tailors a resume to a role perfectly; she recommends debriefing a past interview specifically with ChatGPT.Anna puts Claude on a par with ChatGPT: a resume tailored to the role, interview prep, rehearsing tough questions.
Risks and limitationsTraining on your data is on by default but can be switched off; Anna's ChatGPT sent an email, bypassing her rule.Training on your data is also on by default; Claude adapts Alexander's Russian-language projects to Russian law.

In short: what's the difference

Both names have long stood not for a single chat but for a whole lineup. At OpenAI it is ChatGPT, Codex, Work and the Dots assistant; at Anthropic it is Claude itself, Claude Code, Claude Duet and the Opus and Fable models. These are the two companies Alexander Volchek calls the main leaders, and he advises working with them directly, without aggregators and wrappers. The choice between their assistants, Dots and Claude Duet, he calls a choice of infrastructure, not of model.

Alexander's own split goes like this. Email and services are easier for him to connect on the OpenAI side, since Codex is built on ChatGPT, which Alexander values more than Anthropic's system. For development, though, he picks Claude Code — which, as he puts it, is “cooler than Codex”. In September he discussed a model ranking that, he said, Elon Musk had conditionally endorsed: Claude Opus 5.5 sits in class SSS, ChatGPT-6 Astra in SS and Fable in S, although Alexander personally rates Fable 5.1 higher.

When the hosts choose ChatGPT

Alexander Volchek's first argument for ChatGPT is the infrastructure around everyday life. Over thousands of conversations, the ChatGPT, Codex and Dots combination has learned his daily routine, and Dots comes to him with suggestions on its own and warns him about problems. In the US and a number of other countries, the Finance module connects ChatGPT to practically every financial institution. The host even shops past Amazon more and more often: ChatGPT finds him stores where things are cheaper, and items that can't be found on Amazon at all.

The second argument is limits. For a long time good models in ChatGPT ran practically without restrictions, and Alexander called the most expensive Pro plan, at five hundred dollars, unlimited even on Astra; his cases were built on exactly that — from tens of thousands of pages and a million calls to two hundred thousand tickets. Ilnar Shafigullin considered limits one of OpenAI's main trump cards against Anthropic — and so he was upset when they were cut in half at DevDay. In the episode on job hunting, Anna Volchek praises both systems equally for tailoring a resume to a role, but recommends debriefing a past interview with ChatGPT.

When the hosts choose Claude

Alexander Volchek turns to Claude when the work is complex. He considers Opus 5.5 the best model today for mass development and automation. Fable amazed him even before the model was blocked: launching it in Claude Code straight from his phone by the pool, he watched the model take a big task, described by voice, all the way to the end. And when Fable 5.2 came out, the host moved a task with too much money at stake onto it overnight, because he didn't fully trust Opus 5.5: in complex programming, he says, the new model wins many times over.

Fable, Alexander advises, is for cases where a mistake is costly and the result has to be verified: contracts, finance, finding errors in processes, analyzing advertising and strategy. It also needs a good plan: on the twenty-dollar one it is no use, and it would eat through his two-hundred-dollar subscription in four to five hours. Meanwhile Fable 5.1 costs five to ten times more than Opus 5.5, although it sometimes uses fewer tokens per task. For small everyday things, the host believes, there is probably no need to bring in a model like this.

Claude also has a controversial habit. Although the model has long known that Alexander is American, by default it adapts his Russian-language projects to Russian law, and a landing page for Belarus to Belarusian law. The hosts explain it differently: Ilnar Shafigullin sees the cause in the training data, Alexander thinks the model looks first of all at your location, and Anna Volchek gets all of the AI's advice from a Polish point of view. Alexander's conclusion: know the laws, but don't fall into paranoia.

What has changed in recent months

In the autumn of 2026, both companies reorganized. OpenAI wrote that within the next one to two weeks it would merge ChatGPT and Work and scrap unlimited chat, and Alexander Volchek already notices that ChatGPT no longer handles the data-analysis volumes it used to. Subscription limits were first cut and then, by November, doubled back: on the $200 plan it is once again twenty “x”. Anthropic is stingy with resets — Ilnar Shafigullin explains this by the company having bought capacity for a pessimistic scenario, while demand turned out to be far higher.

One-window assistants have appeared too. Claude Duet came out in preview: access went only to Pro subscribers in the US, and even then through a waitlist. Alexander was quickly disappointed: Duet doesn't see sessions already created in Claude, spends your tokens and, in his view, is aimed more at running a business than at everyday life; he soon stopped using it, calling it an unfinished copy of Dots. Anthropic, on the other hand, released Fable 5.2 and described a memory in which Claude double-checks and corrects its own notes during pauses.

Questions

ChatGPT or Claude: in brief

Is ChatGPT or Claude better?

The ToTheMoon hosts give no single answer. For life, email and services Alexander Volchek prefers ChatGPT, while in development and automation he rates Claude higher, with the Opus 5.5 and Fable models. Comparing models without naming the mode is pointless, he says: in an expensive mode a task is sometimes solved in minutes, while in a basic one it drags on for hours and gets done only partially.

Can I use both ChatGPT and Claude?

Yes, and that is exactly what the hosts do. Alexander Volchek's rule is one main system in which you use every scenario, plus a second, supplementary one if you have the money; a third and a fourth are already hard to work with. Ilnar Shafigullin, when he hits the limits, breaks a task into steps in Claude or ChatGPT and hands the execution to inexpensive models like DeepSeek and Kimi, connected via API through open code.

Is ChatGPT or Claude cheaper?

The plans are similar: both companies have $20 and $200 subscriptions, and OpenAI also has a $500 Pro. The hosts mostly discuss limits. In ChatGPT they were more generous for a long time, although OpenAI is now removing unlimited chat. Claude's limit runs in five-hour windows, and Fable, according to Alexander Volchek, makes no sense on the $20 plan.

Can I trust ChatGPT and Claude with my email and personal data?

The hosts advise keeping an eye on both systems. Training on your data is on by default both in ChatGPT and at Anthropic, but you can uncheck that box. Anna Volchek's ChatGPT sent an email to an online store on its own, even though her rule said the draft had to be approved first. And access to both systems depends on your country, SIM card and payment card, so the hosts advise keeping a backup route.

Where they compared

Episodes where the hosts compare

Other comparisons

More comparisons

All comparisons →